Here, exterior house shutter colors look traditional and timeless because black exterior shutters work well on virtually any home. Even, they can add a touch of elegance and definition. You can’t go wrong, these shutter color looks good with any exterior color, from gray to brown to red to white. They are flattering in any context, much like a little black dress. Black shutters also complement stucco, brick, and stone beautifully. See also: Exterior Paint Color Combinations for Older Homes.